Don’t let profitable distract you from the athletic division’s failures

In sports activities, one factor is put above all else: profitable.

Excuses are made for cheaters and gamblers on the tame finish, and domestic abusers and sex offenders on the acute finish. However so long as they assist your group win, it’s OK. As a result of in sports activities, that’s all that issues, proper?


And Michigan is profitable.

The soccer group simply claimed its second straight Huge Ten Title — carrying out the feat for the primary time since 2003-04 — and secured consecutive Faculty Soccer Playoff appearances for the primary time in program historical past. The boys’s basketball group has made 5 straight Candy 16s. The ladies’s basketball group reached unprecedented heights, making the Elite Eight in final 12 months’s event. The hockey group made it to the Frozen 4 as soon as once more. The gymnastics groups deliver dwelling banners, particular person wrestlers have claimed titles and the suite of different varsity sports activities have discovered nice success.

That success throughout all the athletic division has been cast by laborious work, dedication and — in fact — ethical compromise.

As a result of who wants accountability whenever you’re profitable?

First, flip your eyes to the Huge Ten Championship MVP and sophomore operating again Donovan Edwards. After retweeting antisemitic rhetoric, the athletic division didn’t muster a really sturdy response. Edwards ultimately apologized, solely after saying it was a “glitch” — an unlikely situation given the steps it takes to retweet one thing. College President Santa Ono put out this indirect statement, which fails to deal with Edwards himself or his precise actions. 

Past that? Excuses.

You don’t know Dono like we do.

We heard.

Dono didn’t imply it.

They mentioned.

Dono’s an ideal man.

The road went.

However “Dono” helped them win. That a lot is obvious. So his actions have been brushed below the rug.

Simply this week, senior defensive deal with Mazi Smith confronted felony gun prices. The incident dated again to Oct. 7, however the cost was filed Wednesday, and athletic director Warde Manuel left this lackluster assertion:

“We’re conscious of the cost in opposition to Mazi from a visitors cease again in October,” Manuel mentioned. “Mazi was trustworthy, forthcoming and cooperative from the very starting and is an amazing younger man. He isn’t and by no means has been thought-about a risk to the College or neighborhood. 

“Based mostly on the knowledge communicated to us, we are going to proceed to permit the judicial course of to play out. Mazi will proceed to take part as a member of the group.”

The Wolverines would’ve been hurting with out their star participant and group captain within the Huge Ten Championship sport. After all he was going to play.

I do know that Smith was within the strategy of getting his hid carry license and the opposite info of the case. I’m not right here to say whether or not he’s responsible or not. I’m right here to say the athletic division failed to present substantive reasoning why a participant charged with a felony wasn’t suspended even a sport — as a substitute being lauded within the press launch — or why the information wasn’t disclosed sooner.

Had the athletic division recognized concerning the incident since Oct. 7, this turns into all of the extra sophisticated and all of the extra damning. There’s no method to know, however the previous doesn’t look favorably on the athletic division’s monitor document.

One other star athlete — former level guard Zavier Simpson — additionally confronted prices after a vehicle incident with police in 2020. Simpson, in contrast to Smith, was suspended one sport. The difficulty in his case wasn’t the suspension, however the way in which the athletic division did not correctly handle Simpson mendacity to police that his identify was “Jeff Jackson,” how he was driving a automobile owned by Manuel’s spouse and the way bodycam footage indicated an impaired way of thinking.

Successful took precedence over educating classes and molding younger athletes — over being the “leaders and greatest.”

However passing over critical incidents doesn’t finish there.

In former Michigan hockey coach Mel Pearson’s case, there was a slew of disgusting infractions that Manuel and the division had recognized about for months earlier than firing him earlier this 12 months. It took public outcry earlier than the info of the case have been deemed extreme sufficient to end in motion.

As a result of Pearson was a winner. His gamers have been high prospects at NHL squads and the Wolverines have been within the Frozen 4. Firing Pearson would probably end in a tough 12 months for the Michigan hockey program.

That merely isn’t sufficient to excuse inaction — and there’s actually no different rationalization for it.

Actually, this feigned ignorance and false ethical excessive floor stretches a lot additional again than the previous couple years. Have a look at what’s occurred with Bo Schembechler and the chilling accusations, corroborated by his personal son, levied in opposition to him.

Nonetheless, Michigan coach Jim Harbaugh praises him, and his statue nonetheless stands outdoors the corridor given Schembechler’s namesake on athletic division grounds.


As a result of he was a goddamn winner.

And that shouldn’t be sufficient to pardon any form of conduct.

Not each incident wants a suspension, firing or sweeping handle, however athletes and coaches have to be held accountable for his or her actions. It’s not Manuel and the athletic division’s job to cowl up its pupil’s failures — it’s their job to deal with them correctly.

And if Manuel and his division can’t, they’re those who ought to be held accountable.

Successful packages don’t excuse that.

Stoll might be reached at and on Twitter @nkstoll

Oh hi there 👋
It’s nice to meet you.

Sign up to receive awesome content in your inbox, everyday

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

Oh hi there 👋
It’s nice to meet you.

Sign up to receive awesome content in your inbox, everyday

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

Oh hi there 👋
It’s nice to meet you.

Sign up to receive awesome content in your inbox, everyday

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more info.

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button